ESPN’s Most Popular Show Just Got a Major Shake-Up—And It’s Already Sparking Debate. Molly Qerim’s unexpected exit from ESPN last month sent shockwaves through the sports media world, leaving fans and insiders alike wondering who could possibly fill her shoes on First Take, the network’s flagship debate show. But here’s where it gets controversial: after weeks of speculation and a series of high-profile tryouts, ESPN has officially named Shae Cornette as Qerim’s replacement, a move that’s already dividing opinions. First Take isn’t just any show—it’s the most talked-about platform in sports media, and the pressure to get this decision right was immense.
On Thursday, ESPN confirmed to Front Office Sports that Cornette, a familiar face across the network’s studio shows, including SportsCenter, would step into the role alongside Stephen A. Smith. This marks a significant career milestone for Cornette, who joined ESPN in 2020 after making a name for herself in Chicago covering the Bears for Fox 32 and co-hosting Kap & Co. on ESPN 1000. Her dynamic presence, deep sports knowledge, and ability to command conversations have made her a standout talent, but will she be able to match Qerim’s legacy? That’s the question on everyone’s mind.
And this is the part most people miss: Qerim’s departure wasn’t just sudden—it was shrouded in mystery. Reports initially suggested she’d leave at the end of 2025, but she announced her exit shortly after, leaving colleagues like Stephen A. Smith stunned. Chris "Mad Dog" Russo speculated on the SI Media Podcast that Qerim might have felt "embarrassed" by the early leak, not wanting to be seen as a "lame duck" for the rest of the year. Whether that’s true or not, her abrupt resignation has left many wondering what really happened behind the scenes.
Cornette, for her part, seems ready to take on the challenge. In her own statement, she expressed excitement about joining First Take, calling it a "brand of energy, perspective, and passion" that aligns perfectly with her love for sports. Her first official day is set for November 3, and expectations are sky-high. But here’s the real question: Can Cornette bring the same spark that made Qerim a fan favorite, or will she carve out a new path entirely? What do you think? Is this the right move for ESPN, or should they have gone in a different direction? Let us know in the comments—this debate is just getting started.
